On Iranian Diaspora, Sanctions and Democracy

19 Apr

There have been a number of interesting developments regarding Iran and US in the last couple of days which caught my eye. 

Foremost among them was the survey by the The Public Affairs Alliance of Iranian Americans (PAAIA).

The 2013 PAAIA survey of Iranian Americans had some notable results.

The attitude of Iranian – Americans towards sanctions imposed against the Iranian regime shows that majority of Iranian Americans are not against current sanctions. According to the survey’s findings:

 A large majority of sixty-eight percent (68%) would support the removal of sanctions on Iran if the Iranian regime reached an agreement with the U.S. and the international community concerning its nuclear program.

Note the words: “if the Iranian regime reached an agreement with the U.S. and the international community concerning its nuclear program”.

That means 68% of Iranian – Americans support the sanctions as a tool to pressure the Iranian regime to reach an agreement with the US and the international community over its nuclear program.

This view is supported by another finding of the survey:

Iranian Americans want to see change in Iran. The survey indicates that from among a list of seven issues relating to U.S.-Iran relations, the greatest number of Iranian Americans, fifty-six  percent (56%), cited the promotion of human rights and democracy as the most important, followed by thirty-one percent (31%) who chose promotion of regime change.

Again here it seems that that calls for removal of current sanctions is not the top priority.

This is despite the fact that many Iranians inside and outside of Iran have friends and family who have been affected by the current sanctions.

What could explain this phenomenon?

Its quite possible that after the 2009 mass arrest, torture and execution of Iranian demonstrations, Iranian – Americans see the sanctions as a tool to punish the Iranian regime, which is becoming more unpopular by the Iranian diaspora every day.

The fact that the Obama administration has not imposed sanctions against the sale of food and medicine has probably had an impact as well. This has given the sanctions a less punishing perception, despite the fact that in some cases sanctions have increased food prices. In some cases they have also made some specialized medicines more difficult to acquire inside Iran. Although it is notable that in at least one case, the Iranian regime sent specialized blood medicine which is scarce and in much demand – to its allies in Syria. It seems that the lives of Assad’s forces are more important to Iran’s rulers than the lives of ordinary Iranians.

The desire for the US to pressure the Iranian regime to improve human rights has also now been echoed by a recent letter by Iranian dissidents, many of whom have been inside regime jails.

In my opinion Iran’s supreme leader Khamenei would much rather make compromises on the nuclear program than on human rights, simply because the abuse of human rights is far more important to the survival of his regime than the nuclear program.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: