Egypt: The Mistake of Toppling Morsi

3 Jul

If the Egyptian military topples President Mohamed Morsi, it could be one of the biggest mistakes made in Egypt’s post 2011 revolution history.  

There is no doubt Morsi made many mistakes as president. His government mismanaged the economy. Most ominously, Morsi betrayed the foundations of Egypt’s newly formed democracy when he undemocratically granted himself additional power. 

We saw a clear example of this last year. According to an article on the 22nd of November in the New York Times:

With a constitutional assembly on the brink of collapse and protesters battling the police in the streets over the slow pace of change, President Mohamed Morsi issued a decree on Thursday granting himself broad powers above any court as the guardian of Egypt’s revolution, and used his new authority to order the retrial of Hosni Mubarak.

Morsi sounds pretty bad. So why would the Egyptian army toppling him be a mistake?

Professor Daniel Brumberg, my friend and colleague, has impressive academic credentials. He succinctly explained why toppling Morsi would be a mistake on his Facebook page:

If you want to once and for all discredit Authoritarian Islamism, then defeat it at the polls. A military intervention, even one backed by the street, will never achieve the lasting impact of an electoral defeat, and will always leave the impression that those backing the intervention fear that they cannot win an election. Beware the boomerang!

I agree with Dan. Morsi is bad, but toppling him by force—especially with a military coup d’état—could have serious repercussions in Egypt and perhaps the region for decades to come.

Lets not forget that Morsi is close to the Muslim Brotherhood. If they are driven from power through the barrel of the gun instead of through votes at the ballot box, then they could turn to the gun to try to reclaim their lost position. They could adopt the slogan “What was taken away from us by force can only be returned to us by force.”

A surge of political violence in Egypt—the largest state in the Arab World—could have a ripple effect across the region, driving Islamists away from the democratic political process. The result could create increased Islamic radicalization in the Middle East.

Also, we all want democracy for Egypt, don’t we? So since when toppling democratically elected leaders by force is democratic?

We must also ask the question: would toppling Morsi by force turn Egypt of 2013 into Algeria of 1992 ?

I am not an Egypt expert. There are people such as Brian Whitaker and my colleague Nervana Mahmoud who know Egypt far better than me.  But all I can say is that in my opinion you can’t fix what is a democratic issue through the barrel of the gun. Morsi was elected. He was brought to power through the ballot box, and he must be removed the same way, if stable democracy is what we want.

7 Responses to “Egypt: The Mistake of Toppling Morsi”

  1. Seyed Enayatollah Dastgheibi July 3, 2013 at 11:24 pm #

    This is a naive understanding of the workings of the moslem fundamentalists. During his term of office, Morsi would have put in place all the apparatus to perpetuate the Moslem Brotherhood’s rule till doom’s day. It is to say that the Nazi regime could have been defeated through ballot box; or the communists for that.

  2. Patrick July 3, 2013 at 11:35 pm #

    the Egyptian army follow the will of more than 24 milion Egyptians who have signed a petition for the departure of Morsi. That changes everything

  3. inbarip July 4, 2013 at 1:26 pm #

    Meir did not former elections in Iran told us that you cannot change Moslem regime in the ballot?


  1. What next for Egypt? | The Iran-Israel Observer - July 4, 2013

    […] day after the coup in Egypt: I still standby what I said in my post yesterday. Toppling Morsi was a mistake. He was a bad president, but this was not the way to  remove him. He […]

  2. Popular Coup Stymies Democracy in Egypt | The Washington Middle East Observer - July 9, 2013

    […] no longer buys into the idea of democracy. It could also mean an uptick in violence, as many could use violence in an attempt to regain power—or simply to disrupt and destabilize the process. Many groups affiliated with the Muslim […]

  3. Egypt: Where is the rage from the international community? | The Iran-Israel Observer - July 28, 2013

    […] you imagine the rage if the army of a country which is not an ally of the West had deposed the democratically elected government and started killing its own population in such a […]

  4. Video: Inside the Muslim Brotherhood | The Iran-Israel Observer - August 7, 2013

    […] the recent coup d’état against Morsi, one of the important questions has been: what is happening inside the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood? […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: